Not everything you see on the internet is what it seems...

You need to be ‘webwise’ when you are surfing the web, chatting with friends , sharing files or playing games on the Internet.

Explore the cyber-worlds on this website and you will find games, video clips and advice on how to be safe on your online adventures.

Tell us about your Online Adventures...

Is the Internet bad for Music?

The content of this Argument is aimed at post-primary students, especially those in Senior Cycle and Transition Year..

More and more people are illegally sharing music over the Internet. The music industry says that it hurts musicians and is effectively 'stealing'. Those who download the music argue that it is the way of the future and that they are actually supporting music.

What do you think? Consider the views below and make your decision.

What is the argument all about?

Recording artist Mundy says . . .
"I am a recording artist and I release all my own records at the moment. I think that i may loose out on record sales due to file sharing but people are still getting to hear my music. Personally, any music that i have ever been given for free and it isn't my cuppa I'm not going to listen to it or wanna buy it. I have recently started to purchase music from I Tunes and have noticed that all you get is the album and the front cover..you can't see the lyrics or who played or produced it etc.. personally I think if you are a true fan of the music..you'd want an original copy of the album..!!
(Mundy)

No, the Internet is great for music

Yes, it leads to online piracy

Have Your Say

 Tell us what you think

Your Comments

"Hey, I think that it is bad but it has it adventages. People say that its "free" but you probably will end up getting spam mail after "purchasing". Its good in the sense that you can find almost the wierdest and coolest bands that don't sell in the shops. Before you purchase it, think of the musicians and there income? Its from people BUYING their CD's not copying files... Oh, and I love the Shins..."
(Diane)

"ipods and mp3 players are the future why have cds and cd players when you could have all your favorite songs at the push of a button (and there cheap too)"
(Laura)

"DOWNLOADING MUSIC ROCKS EVEN IF YOU GET IT FROM AN ALEGEL SITE WHO CARES IT'S NOT LIKE YOU ARE ROBING SOMEONE OF MUSIC I MEAN LIKE ITS JUST UNFARE THAT PEOPLE CAN JUST TELL THE GAURDS THAT YOU WERE GETTING MUSIC THAT IS COPY RIGHT "
(Ian G)

"HEY YA..Everyone should be able to download their favourite song because it is a good idea."
(Stacey Cahill)

"No it's great - I get music for free"
(Anonymous)

"I hate paying for music."
(Evan)

"Downloading music is a revolution. No longer will we have to rip cd's and convert songs into mp3's......"
(Hank)

"Gazza saying downloading theme songs of tv shows and moives is ok because you can't buy them but downloading songs you can get from a CD is wrong "
(Gazza Prime)

"Hi!!I think it is brilliant because it is easier and cheaper to buy my Nirvana cds!! The internet ROCKS!!"
(Anonymous - Kildare)

"Well i think you should be able to down load because its cheep and the price of cd's is well too expensive and if you can get them for free why not? Also if there's only one song you like of the artist you don't need to buy the whole album for one song. It is also good because you don't need to leave your house so for all us lazy people it's great."
(Michelle)

"I think it's great to be able to download music and videos from the internet. For some people who are actually ADVENTUROUS about which music they listen to, you have a chance to listen to music you wouldn't nomally listen to."
(Danielle B)

"Artists can't expect people to pay up to €25 for a CD if they only like two or three songs on the album. If they dropped their prices maybe people wouldn't download music off the internet. A lot of their fans are young and can't afford to buy CD's so,of course they're going to steal it if possible. As for using the word 'steal' the music companies are the real robbers! "
(Emma)

"I think it's really cool to download music. I find it amazing how the internet works. Downloading music is fascinating! "
(Doreen)

"I think its the best idea anyone has come up with because it's free and you can download the songs you like onto a cd and not buy the cd because you mightn't like the band but you like the song!!!!"
(Rachel)

"I think its the best idea anyone has come up with because its free and you can download the songs you like onto a cd and not buy the cd because you mightn't like the band but you like the song!!!!"
(Kiaya Foster)

"I think its a very good idea and who ever thaught of the idea is a genius and it's better to keep your money for something better and if you like a song and not the band you can download the song instead of buying the album "
(Lizzie G)

"I think that downloading music is a good idea.- you get all the songs you like to listen to, and you don't have to buy the albums, which have rubbish songs anyway.this way you get the songs that YOU want"
(Mary Louise)

"I think downloading music frm the internet is a gr8 idea, because its free. Even though its bad 4 the music industry bcoz they dont make any money frm it, its still deadly. Anyway, who cares about about the music industry! They make enough money as it is! So i think music should be free!!"
(Bobbi)

"I think downloading music off the internet is a good idea because many songs on an album aren't good and its a waste of money buying the album for one song. "
(Anonymous)

"I think free internet music is a great way for any person to find any song that may intrest them even if they havn't got the money to purchase a cd made by the artist. The artist can have merchandise and concerts that can get them money and they have the support of all their fans even the ones that would not usually be able to afford a cd."
(Saz)

"I think it is a good idea to be able to download music off the internet because music artists are getting enough money anyway so what's every one complining about?! Its deadly and cheap and anyone who disagrees sucks!!"
(Loretta)

"I think that you should be able to to buy music off the internet because it is good and it does not rip you off .You can see what you are buying and see the artists "
(Rachel C)

"I think getting music off the internet is good because it's easier to get to and cheaper.It's good for people who can't get out that much!"
(Emer)

"I think it's good to download music and what if the artists aren't getten any money for it - they shouldn't be so selfish."
(Kelly)

"I think that it is good because if someone doesn't like a band but likes one of their songs then they can just download it instead of paying for a full album in the shops"
(Carolann McMahon)

"I think music on the internet is a great idea because you can buy just one song instead of buying a whole album"
(Lyndsey, Dublin)

"Heh Gazza saying downloadable music is bad as it ruins the companies that make the music "
(Gazza Prime)

"As a dance teacher at the colaiste iognaid school in Galway I find it extremely easy to download music for my classes."
(Liam)

"I think Blogging is a very good way too tell people what you think about the net.Children should use it in class and tell people about useing blogging.Teach people about how to use web wise and also about blogging."
(Lucia Evans)"

"Parents should not allow children under 10 on the net on there own because they wouldn't know what to do and kids between 10 and 16 should be watched because they could be downloading music illeagaly."
(Ciara “O'Shea)

"I think parents should not allow their children on the net without having Parental supervision.So that parents know what there children are up to while using the net.Children who are 11 and 12 should be more muture not to steal."
(Orlaith O'Connor)

"The internet is cool but you should be aware of the dangers. If you are going to download make sure you know what sites to go to . I love music but I wouldn't steal a cd. So don't steal music off the internet. Bye Bye."
(Supergirl)

"Hello Everyone! There are two sides of selling music on the net. If you burn cds and keep on giving your files away thats the bad thing about having music on the net. If you buy the cds on the web thats good because your not stealling."
(Orlaith O'Connor)

In a way it is good downloading music but you have to be careful because you could get in trouble. You should pay for ALL music.
(Jean, Newcastlewest)

"I think that music on the internet is very bad because the artists that sing the songs won't get any money and it's just ripping them off."
Maria Ryan

"Bhíodh na CDs ró-dhaor in Éirinn. Fiú inniu táid an-dhaor ar fad 'sna siopaí agus san Eoraip tá na cinn chéanna i bhfad níos saoire..cén fath??? Is ceart íoc as íoslódail amhrán ón Web as rachfaidh an t-airgead do na ceolteoirí...ar phraghas ceart!!! Break the monopoly of the BIG Music Colmpanies agus cuir gach ar fáil, do gach duine ar phraghas íseal agus féaralta."
(Daithí Ó Murchú)

"I think downloading music from the internet is a good idea. It is a good idea for students who haven't got a job or money to buy the full album when they probely won't even listen to all the songs!"
(Jenni)

"I think the internet is great for downloading music - it should not be stopped and the people who think it shouuld are crazy and out of there minds ."
(Anonymous)

"I think the internet is bad for music because bands are not getting money when people illegally download songs""
(Shane Crossan)

"I think the internet is great for music because if people only want one song from an album they can get it without spending all their money on songs they don't want"
(David Eustace)

"I think that artists are loosing out on alot of money because of the net"
(Michael O'Sullivan)

"No the internet is not bad for music because you don't have to pay twenty euro for your music and sometimes you might even get lucky and you could get free music"
(Bill Foley)

"I think there should be no free downloadable music as recording songs costs a lot of moey."
(Gary Moloney)

"The internet rocks for music because you can buy music off your computer instead of going down to a shop to get a cd"
(Dan Sweeney)

"Music on the internet is a bad idea because it is ripping off good artists."
(Thomas Philpott)

"I think the internet is great for music. I think it should be a bit cheaper because its realy dear and its not like the artist isn't making enough money anyway!"
(David)

"No, we need music and this is the next leval."
(Eoghan McConvile)

"I think it is a fabulous idea! It is a breakthrough for the music industry!"
(Sarah)

"It is good for music because of faster acces to good music and to downloadables. It is also bad if they don't give you what you want and if you can't do anything about it "
(James Porter)

"I think the Internet is ultimately great for music as it can share peoples' thoughts and feelings and can help people to cope with tragedys. It brings happiness and energy to people and overall helps the human socioty. "
(Raquel)

"I think file sharing is great. Music shoud be free and besides bands make loads of money. Are you going to have free music on scoilnet?"
(Mondo McGrath)

Editor: No plans for free music. Sorry!

"If we all sang to each other every day the world would be a better place and there'd be no violence and hate. "Thank you for the music the songs I'm singing thanks for all the love you've bringing.""
(Lisa Patterson)

"No its great. There are some websites that play music for free!!"
(Rachel)

"I think if a musician is starting out the Internet can be a great way of promoting his/her music.Sure beats handing out flyers!"
(John in Cobh)

 I think although downloading music is good, I think people should pay for it. If you're an artist you usually release music to make money right? Downloading music for free is going to kill off the industry!!! Artists won't make money and thus won't be able to make more music!!!
Melancholy